XMP handoff guide

XMP Ratings from PickSnap to Lightroom Classic and Capture One

PickSnap can export star ratings in optional XMP sidecars for a local handoff to Lightroom Classic or Capture One. XMP is off by default; originals remain untouched. Keep each exported photo with its sidecar and test the receiving editor before a full transfer. Proprietary RAW, JPEG and DNG do not all use metadata the same way.

Published by PickSnap.

PickSnap is our product. This guide separates our workflow suggestions from facts in the linked official documentation. It is not a speed benchmark or an independent product ranking.

Short answer

Use an exported keeper folder for the selection itself and XMP when you also need stars. PickSnap is free on Apple Silicon Macs and Windows x64 and does not upload photographs. This page describes an editor handoff, not a claim that every editor version has passed a round-trip compatibility test.

Metadata handoff comparison — official documentation checked 2026-10-29
ApplicationDocumented metadata behaviorCheck before a full handoff
PickSnap 1.3.8Optional rating/rotation sidecars on export; source photographs remain unchanged. Product facts.Enable XMP and retain each exported photo with its matching sidecar.
Lightroom ClassicAdobe distinguishes proprietary RAW sidecars from embedded XMP in JPEG, TIFF, PSD and DNG.A JPEG or DNG beside an XMP file is not equivalent to a proprietary RAW sidecar workflow.
Capture OneOfficial XMP documentation describes manual Load Metadata and one-way Load versus two-way Full Sync.Start with a small sample and inspect the actual ratings.

What an XMP sidecar is

An XMP sidecar is a small metadata file beside a photograph. In a typical proprietary RAW pair, DSC_0123.NEF and DSC_0123.xmp share a stem. PickSnap writes a rating value and applicable rotation metadata when you enable XMP on export. It does not turn the sidecar into a new image or develop your RAW.

Keep both files together, including after any rename. PickSnap may rename exported copies to avoid a name collision; use the actual exported pair, not the original basename you remember. PickSnap does not automatically apply a JPEG's decision to its RAW companion.

Lightroom Classic steps

  1. In PickSnap, rate a small set of proprietary RAW photos. Export copies to an empty folder with XMP enabled.
  2. Import those copies into Lightroom Classic and inspect the star ratings before making edits.
  3. If needed, select the test images and use Metadata > Read Metadata from File. Adobe documents this command for applying external metadata and notes that it replaces catalog settings. Read Adobe’s metadata instructions before applying it to already-edited images.
  4. Once your sample behaves as intended, repeat the same handoff for the selected set.

This sequence is for Lightroom Classic. We have not verified identical behavior in cloud Lightroom. For the complete first-pass workflow, see PickSnap vs Lightroom.

Capture One steps

  1. Export a few rated copies with XMP enabled, and open or import them in your Capture One workflow.
  2. Select them and use Image > Load Metadata. Check their stars.
  3. If you want automatic loading, review the Image preferences: Load reads sidecars; Full Sync also writes back. Use manual loading for the first test.

Capture One’s documentation explains metadata precedence and warns that Full Sync can affect performance on large sets. Check “Prefer Sidecar XMP over Embedded Metadata” if competing metadata is being preferred. Its documentation also notes that same-stem RAW and JPEG files can share a sidecar; do not assume that this makes PickSnap's separate decisions identical.

Troubleshooting: JPEG vs RAW, and reading metadata

  • No sidecar appeared: XMP is off by default in PickSnap. Enable it and export a new test set.
  • Wrong files are open: check whether the editor is viewing the original folder or the exported copies, and whether the sidecar stem matches.
  • JPEG, TIFF, PSD or DNG stars are missing: Adobe documents embedded XMP for these formats. PickSnap's separate sidecar is not a promise that Lightroom Classic will read it for those formats. Use the keeper folder for selection or rate inside the editor after import.
  • Existing catalog ratings differ: inspect metadata conflicts on a sample. Do not overwrite an edited catalog or an existing sidecar just to force the stars to match.
  • Keep/reject flags are missing: PickSnap marks are not a verified cross-editor flag mapping. The exported selection folder carries the keeper decision.
  • Rotation or crop looks different: editor interpretation varies. PickSnap does not offer RAW crop editing; check the actual exported output rather than assuming full edit interchange.

For source-file safety and defaults, see the homepage FAQ and product facts.

Frequently asked questions

Does PickSnap modify RAW files?

No. PickSnap leaves original RAW photographs unchanged. Desktop export copies the selected photos; optional XMP sidecars carry ratings and rotation metadata separately. XMP is off by default.

Why don’t my ratings appear?

Check that XMP was enabled, the editor is opening the exported copy, and the matching sidecar is beside it. Then inspect the editor’s metadata-loading settings on a small sample. File format matters, and we have not verified every editor version.

Do JPEGs use sidecars?

PickSnap exports separate sidecars, but Lightroom Classic normally embeds XMP in JPEGs. JPEG-sidecar ratings are therefore not guaranteed to appear. PickSnap does not automatically copy JPEG decisions to companion RAWs.

Continue your culling workflow

Explore PickSnap, the 2026 photo culling software guide, and our Photo Mechanic alternative comparison. For the complete product limits, see features and specifications.

Last verified: . Official documentation was checked on this date; editor behavior can vary by version and file format.